Home : About Us :commun-iT blog  

commun-iT blog

Employee sacked while on sick leave wins compensation

Wednesday, May 23, 2012
A recent case in the Federal Magistrates Court of Australia (‘the Court’) has found than an employer unfairly dismissed an employee while she was on sick leave.

As the employee’s salary was over the unfair dismissal threshold of $118,100, the employee commenced proceedings under s 352 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (‘the Act’). This section prohibits an employer from dismissing an employee for being “temporarily absent from work due to illness or injury” of a type allowed pursuant the Act. An acceptable illness or injury is that which can be proven by evidence, such as a medical certificate.

The employee had fallen ill and had taken sick leave in compliance with the terms of her employment contract and notified the employer that she would be taking a week of sick leave, and would produce a medical certificate at her first available opportunity. Two days into her sick leave, and before she was able to do provide a medical certificate, the employer summarily dismissed her. Among other reasons, the termination letter stated that the employee “had failed” to keep the employer aware of their “absences”.

The employer had also refused to provide one month’s written notice as required in the employment contract, alleging that the employee had engaged in either “serious misconduct or wilful neglect”, or another act capable of allowing termination under the employment contract the action of dismissing the employee was unrelated to the employee’s lawful sick leave, or that the conduct of the employee amounted to valid reasons to summarily terminate her employment. Federal Magistrate Smith said that the employer’s “decision was poorly thought through” and the act of summary dismissal itself was “devoid of objective reasonableness and fairness” to the employee.

The Court ordered the employer be fined $20,000, pay compensation to the employee of more than $37,000 and cover the employee’s legal costs of $57,000.

For advice on sick leave provisions or termination of employment contact Nick Stevens or Liza Isho.

Author: Nick Stevens, Principal, Stevens & Associates Lawyers, an AIIA.biz expert and one of the Panel of Expert Bloggers.

This article provides general information only. It is not legal advice, and is not a substitute for legal advice. Specific advice should be sought to take into account your particular circumstances. Stevens & Associates Lawyers is a boutique industrial relations and employment law firm. It has liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.

Trackback Link
Post has no trackbacks.

Subscribe to the commun-iT blog RSS

 Recent Posts


loans AIIA personal income tax Discounted Deals dividends flood insurance Capability Study 2011 Supply Management Fee copyright IT Contracts Law eServices Panel of Expert Bloggers IT Lawyer GST Michael Blumenstein Insurance Advisernet Nick Stevens Australian Business Register small business owners Civil Aviation Regulations Hotel contractual obligations Consumer Law termination Gold Coast ICT Forum employers SME IT Law AUSkey Financial Planning Advanced Findings Contractor company tax ATO restraint Greg Tomkins reseller Maat Solutions leave loading Travel government procurement Peta Maloney Superannuation Guarantee Division 7A Research and Development Tax Credit SAAS Fair Work Commission Corporate and Commercial Law confidentiality clause Mike Pym director duties Tax Information gathering Benefits industrial action discounted travel Centennial Financial Services patent personal services income Fair Work Regulations unfair dismissal open source Innovation Australia: AusIndustry Tax rates Confidential information Contracting Software Research and Development Tax, www.aiia.biz managed services IT Forum Gold Coast award Insurance Payment Summaries fuel tax credits fraudulent refunds Independent ICT capability study IAAS Compliance Program Queensland State Government moral right employment law Fair Work Australia R&D tax Credit restraint of trade clause Research and Development Tax employment agreements Australian Workplace Agreements warranty against defects ASIC Sham Employment Greg Pearce underpayment Australian Information Industry Assocation IT Professionals Matthew Karpanen Government Grants Alex Bodnar broker Professional Idemnity Compulsory Employer Superannuation 2020 Federal Court of Australia ABN Procure IT breach of employment contract Survey data tax law small business Regulation 90 term deposit natural disaster selling your business indemnity adverse action Fringe Benefit PAYG Databases Clerical and Administrative Employees (State) Award 12 percent Falsify sick leave individuals withholding rates Stevens and Associates Board of Taxation breach of implied terms IP Software R&D Tax compliance warranties Guide David Scott NES fines Living Away from Home Allowance ITFGC Balance Professional Services Agreements Win an iPad 2 Fair Work Act IT capability directory employee enterprise agreement employment contract superannuation benchmarking Free Basic Listing Pym's Technology Lawyers Tours National Employment Standards distribution agreement AIIA.biz unpaid work Treadstone Fair Work Ombudsman Peter Nolle PAAS


    Our Expert Bloggers

    Mike Pym

    Mike is an entrepreneur and lawyer who leads two SMEs, one in the IT software industry, and a firm of lawyers specialising in IT law.

    Peta Maloney

    Company and commercial law, shareholder agreements, constitutions, directors’ duties, setting up companies, IT contracts, outsourcing, government procurement and privacy.

    Peter Nolle

    Government Grants from start up to export ready

    Alex Bodnar

    General insurance advisory for commercial & industrial risks, 
    Information Technology & Telecommunication exposures. 

    David Scott

    Investments, Superannuation,
    Life Insurance, Income Protection Insurance, Key Person Insurance, Debt Management, Gearing,
    Retirement Planning

    Mike Pym

    IT contracts, government procurement of IT, distribution agreements, outsourcing, contract management & dispute resolution.

    Nick Stevens

    Enterprise Agreements,
    Employment Contracts,
    Unfair Dismissal, EEO, 
    Workplace Surveillance & Privacy, OH&S

    Industry Associations



    Maat Solutions Pty Ltd
    Level 6, 60 Pitt Street
    Sydney NSW Australia

    T: +61 (02) 9247 9459
    F: +61 (02) 9247 9550

    Captcha Image